Sunday, February 18, 2018

"My Glock is my equalizer": twisting women's rights

We cry and grieve for the lost children, the life long agony of their families, the incomprehensibility of our country's continued gun fetish. 
We, you and me, and your friends and my friends read Michael Tomasky (Daily Beast) & Adam Gopnik (New Yorker). We ask big, discourse-worthy questions about society and our democracy. 




 We frame the gun problem using things like criminal justice studies, social pathology, cycles of poverty and economic interests. We speak of the ethical and the moral.




We ask?
  • What does it say about a society that has more handguns per capita than war-torn countries like Yemen,?
  • How can we accept the fact that 5,740 young people died from gunfire in the United States, just in 2008 and 2009.
  • Why can't our children go to school, shopping malls, movies, concerts without the threat of being slaughtered by someone with a war weapon?
  • How can we allow elected officials to accept millions $$$ from the NRA?
  • Why can't this great democracy pass sensible gun legislation?
BUT who is fueling the pro gun movement even at this moment. We're familiar with the usual argument frames:
  • freedom from state tyranny
  • constitutional rights
  • militia madness
But with the Florida HS shooting I found myself consuming lots of commentary, trying to make some meaning out of the chaos.

I discovered (PragerU) "Short Videos Big Ideas".  Their website boasts:

Our videos make it easy to get smarter five minutes at a time


 
https://www.prageru.com/5-minute-ideas#search

I'm writing in this entry about a specific "show' they have presented by Katie Pavlich

 http://bit.ly/2Bzb1CW




Here the narrative is more pernicious. 

It has critical elements of persuasive argument: (I'll use Aristotle here circa 386 BC)




1.  She has a STRONG INTRODUCTION
                   "My Glock 43 is my equalizer"
                    "Don't you want equality between men and women. 
 
2.  She speaks  in an honest,  straight forward style. (Ethos)

                 "How is a woman supposed to defend herself" - against a man who is bigger and stronger.

3.  She asks the viewers to explore together "let's just think bout this".  (Pathos)

4.  She uses compelling real world, real people evidence for her argument, with clear, easy       consumable visuals (logos). 

5. She "closes" strong.

      "I'm all for equality between the sexes...that's why I own a gun." 

Forget the cherry-picked research comparing English and American crime rates.
She's got the   "real people" stories like the female mail carrier who took matters into her own hands when the police turned a deaf ear. 
 
 
 
And there you have it. 
Smarter in 5 minutes!




Wednesday, February 7, 2018

Is this the new face of disaster relief??

Im stewing about an issue that should be so much lower on the “ do something useful for mankind today” totem poll today that it’s turning out to be.  

Perhaps it’s because I’m in Greece at the moment and here you can certainly get your fill of the Byzantine web of political infighting, nepotism, idiotic bureaucracy, and a little too much Retsina, to be at your best every day. 

The latest in FEMA dysfunction has hit my gender button (among others) and is messing with far more than my Aegean day.

FEMA Contract Called for 30 Million Meals for Puerto Ricans. 50,000 Were Delivered.


The facts as reported in the NYT

Immediately after apocalyptic Hurricane Harvey and Puerto Rico’s utter devastation, FEMA determined that at least 30 million meals were needed to be there right away. 

Who did they choose to meet this enormous challenge? 
Tiffany Brown, the sole proprietor of Tribute LLC. 

This is the website I found: She has a number of companies - some in fashion.


I quote the NYT,   


"Ms. Brown, who is adept at navigating the federal contracting system, hired a wedding caterer in Atlanta with a staff of 11 to freeze-dry wild mushrooms and rice, chicken and rice, and vegetable soup. She found a nonprofit in Texas that had shipped food aid overseas and domestically, including to a Houston food bank after Hurricane Harvey."

Comes Oct. 2017 Brown’s contract was ended  - why? 
Because she only had delivered 50,000 out of a total 30 million meals.  BTW the meals showed up separately packed from the heaters that people needed to make them eatable.

So, the moral of this story....
Yes, once again we see that, as with Hurricane Katrina, FEMA’s system for responding does not work.  They don’t seem to have vetted, proven contractors in place before disasters hit. 

Secondy - we don't know just how they chose Tyfanny Brown and Tribute LLC. 

It seems food service may not be Tribute’s thing.  Quoting the NYT again,Four cancellations involved the Federal Prison System, which found that Tribute failed to deliver meat, bakery, cereal and other food products to various correctional institutions.”

But here is what else has so soured my Aegean day, the devastated US citizens that needed to be fed backgrounded for a moment,

The art and crime of giving government contracts ( local and national) to insiders is nothing new.  I get it.  The “old boys” network – etched in our culture and capitalism, is not going away soon.


But now, it really does hit me that there is and will likely grow an “old gals” network of savvy female insiders, who have their fingers in the pot. 
According to Brown's multi-business website:

She has held positions with the United States Government Accountability

Office, Fulton County District Attorney’s Office, Georgia Law Center for the
Homeless, Georgia Conservation Voters, Supreme Court of Georgia, Equifax,
Coca-Cola Enterprises, and Atlanta Bar Association. Upon Graduation from
Walden University, she has truly impacted change as an academic and
practitioner. Dr. Brown is a former 2009 Write-in Atlanta Mayoral Candidate
and owner of 3 companies.

Tiffany Brown’s Tribute LLC, as far as I can tell, was certified as a Women Owned/Minority Owned Business ( WMBE).  Coincidentally my small consulting business is too.  *Disclaimer I don’t do food delivery, or claim to be able to feed any one besides myself and my dog on a regular basis. 

But I do respect, support and believe in the mission of the WMBE federal program.

  • “We promote equity and increase participation in public contracting and procurement for small businesses owned by minorities, women and disadvantaged persons through education and certification. 
  • Creating an environment where small businesses owned by minorities, women and disadvantaged persons have equal opportunity to participate in public contracting and procurement.


Emboldened by the #MeToo movement  - Yes. 
But I'm also sobered to be reminded again, that this is one of the ugly upshots of women getting ahead.  The age old tradeoff of ethics for ....what, status, power and money.  


“You can only become truly accomplished at something you love. Don’t make money your goal. Instead, pursue the things you love doing, and then do them so well that people can’t take their eyes off you.” -Maya Angelou